Hacker News

Powered by HN Search API

SpaceX’s Falcon Heavy successfully launches

From https://techcrunch.com/2018/02/06/spacexs-historic-falcon-heavy-successfully-launches/?ncid=rss&utm_source=dlvr.it&utm_medium=twitter
mpweiher | 2018-02-06 | 2968

Comments:

Meerax

2018-02-06
YES!

zhoujianfu

2018-02-06
There was something doubly awesome about the two falcons landing at the same time right next to each other!

adt2bt

2018-02-06
And both boosters landed simultaneously!

That was seriously impressive to watch. Congratulations to all the SpaceX engineers who made this a reality.

ASipos

2018-02-06
yes!

dopamean

2018-02-06
That was incredible. Watching the double landing of the boosters I couldn't help but feel like we live in the future. It was actually a little emotional.

ekrebs

2018-02-06
Watching those boosters land side-by-side made me question my reality. Beautiful.

TeMPOraL

2018-02-06
I. Am. Just. Speechless.

Perfect takeoff, 2 simultaneous landings (still waiting for confirmation on the droneship landing), the car is in orbit.

I don't remember being so nervous watching a launch video since... Space Shuttle missions, I think.

Great job, SpaceX!

pestrov

2018-02-06
So what about the core?

javaes

2018-02-06
Impressive! But what happened to the core?

ptrincr

2018-02-06
That was really impressive. Does anyone know what happened to the core? Seemed to lose feed to the drone ship.

ASipos

2018-02-06
any link to the center core landing video?

globuous

2018-02-06
Absolutely amazing. Just watched it live, gave me goosebumps. Although:

"SpaceX also attempted a recovery of all three of the first stage boosters it used during the launch. It has recovered two of those thus far, and we’re waiting to hear back from SpaceX on the official status of the final, third booster, which was landing at sea."

nafizh

2018-02-06
Anybody saw the 'Don't panic' thing on the Tesla? Made me chuckle, they sure have a sense of humor.

djaychela

2018-02-06
That was like watching a sci fi film when the two cores landed.... I watched it with my mother (who is 80!), and she said it was as significant as the moon landing.

Do we know the fate of the centre core yet?

pilom

2018-02-06
The stream cut out before they were able to report on the main engine recovery. Anyone have more info?

gordon_freeman

2018-02-06
still waiting for CORE to land but ohh boy..was that awesome to see both the boosters land together at the same time.

alexdumitru

2018-02-06
I hope the main core landed successfully too.

franzb

2018-02-06
Absolutely amazing, we watched science-fiction today.

Anyone knows what happened to the core booster?

ChuckMcM

2018-02-06
One of those "this must be the future" moments for sure. I'm really amazed that there is a Tesla Roadster on its way to Mars at this point. That blows my mind.

scientician

2018-02-06
Cried proud human tears today.

Even if the droneship didn't work out...

irln

2018-02-06
The booster landings were incredible, however, the initial shot of it clearing the pad looked like a scifi movie intro.

JustAnotherPat

2018-02-06
Amazing to see. Hard to imagine if not for Musk, we'd be stuck with ULA garbage and a realistic Mars tripped planned for 2050+

crsv

2018-02-06
It was so captivating to watch the launch production. Just watching this test launch you can see how SpaceX is recapturing the hearts and minds of the world and generating the same level of wonder that NASA did in it's hay-day. It's a proud day in annals of mankind and engineering. What an absolute feat. Congratulations to everyone on the team at SpaceX.

alangibson

2018-02-06
Yet another incredible show from SpaceX. At this point, if they said they were going to build a football stadium on Europa, my only question would be when does it open.

But I couldn't help but laugh at the fact that they can launch a massive rocket on the first try and land (at least) 2 cores, but the camera STILL cuts out on the drone ship.

DonaldPShimoda

2018-02-06
I'm just an amateur following along, but this seems likely to be one of the most important launches in modern rocketry history. This sets the stage for deep-space missions with reusable launch materials, which can greatly reduce the cost of future space exploration. Absolutely incredible achievement by the SpaceX team.

shyrka

2018-02-06
Absolutely outstanding! Incredible footage watching the simultaneous landings! Landmark achievement

neilprosser

2018-02-06
It got a little dusty in my house when those two boosters landed. I think someone was cutting onions too.

yohann305

2018-02-06
It seems SpaceX has even perfected its tests to the point that their simulations are doing an amazing job at predicting real life situations. Great job on spaceX. Today History was made, and the new generation of children is inspired to choose space-focused careers

arekkas

2018-02-06
Man, the lift off, separation, landing, and don't panic sugared with Bowie. How great was it to witness that?

dancek

2018-02-06
The official YouTube live broadcast video by SpaceX is at: https://youtu.be/wbSwFU6tY1c

snake117

2018-02-06
Seeing both boosters land side-by-side was absolutely an epic moment. Showing Star Man in the Tesla Roadster with the text displaying "Don't Panic" was just amazing. Very grateful that SpaceX allows us to join in on the excitement. I can't wait to see what comes next!

LoSboccacc

2018-02-06
I wonder for how long we're going to get images from that tesla. there's no power source so the stream will end, but it does sit next some very huge batteries so let's hope it's going to last and we'll be able to check with the spaceman every now and then!

nik736

2018-02-06
Any news on the core?

halamadrid

2018-02-06
What an amazing feat! Well done SpaceX. Hope the core made it too!

MBCook

2018-02-06
So the car is supposed to be in an Earth-Mars orbit. It it stable or is it designed to fall to earth at some point soon (say one or two orbits)?

debt

2018-02-06
Elon over there landing rockets on drone ships, I'm over here finishing a new photo app.

Elon over there going to Mars, I can't even get this dang app to build.

Might be time to move....

http://www.spacex.com/careers

crocal

2018-02-06
I am stuck in the worst traffic jam in Paris since 10 years. Bah. Who cares? :D That was insane!

buildbuildbuild

2018-02-06
Love that SpaceX’s own team shoots, announces, and switches the live production in-house rather than hiring a production company.

Also love seeing machinists side by side cheering with software engineers, standing by a mission control which is placed feet from where engines are assembled on the shop floor.

Open company culture well-executed.

Congratulations to all there!

alistproducer2

2018-02-06
I could've done without the constant clapping and screaming on the webcast. Kinda took away from the experience for me.

weej

2018-02-06
Unbelievable. The simultaneous booster landings were incredibly impressive feat. Outstanding launch and spectacular landings!

Screen shots from live feed: https://imgur.com/a/gh410

davidw

2018-02-06
Wow, beautiful and moving to see people building wonderful things. Have been focused on politics for a while and it's really a breath of fresh air. Made my day!

omot

2018-02-06
I think it's worth noting that NASA wasn't the one to accomplish this, it was a private company. It makes me hopeful that there might be a real possibility of huge infrastructure development by private companies, because it seems like the government is unable to organize itself to accomplish huge infra projects like in the past.

aaron-lebo

2018-02-06
What's the difference in how SpaceX is run vs Musk's other companies? It seems to succeed doing the hardest things whereas the others have struggled to meet their goals.

Would Musk focusing only on it make any difference?

edit: This is not a complaint, just a question, why the downvotes? I'm used to getting downvoted for no reason, but this is basic a question, with great answers. Come on HN! We can't ask questions?

kbyatnal

2018-02-06
Saw this on their careers page right after the landing. Looks like it worked!

https://i.imgur.com/noM0glO.jpg

jonkiddy

2018-02-06
A truly historic moment. Well done SpaceX!

perilunar

2018-02-06
"There's a starman waiting in the sky He's told us not to blow it Cause he knows it's all worthwhile"

lisper

2018-02-06
That was amazing. But... what happened to the core?

outworlder

2018-02-06
Double landing of reused boosters. No matter how you slice it, it's quite a feat.

noonespecial

2018-02-06
Remembered watching an old Star Trek film where the Cochrane character wouldn't launch without playing "Magic Carpet Ride" on the way up and thinking that space travel could never ever be so glib...

Well played Mr. Musk. Well Played.

slfnflctd

2018-02-06
I stopped everything and set aside time to sit and watch the whole thing. It was like seeing magic made real, only better, rapturous. Very emotional launch.

typicalbender

2018-02-06
Sounds like they lost the center core (might just mean the signal its not clear), hell of a showing though the team should be really proud of the accomplishment.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-B_tWbjFIGI&feature=youtu.be...

jagger27

2018-02-06
Does anyone have a "top-down" view of the Roadster's (planned) orbit? I've read that it's on a Hohmann transfer towards Mars's orbital neighbourhood but haven't seen a diagram.

songzme

2018-02-06
delete

Shivetya

2018-02-06
the coolest part to me is watching both boosters touch down in sight of each other at the same time. that was science fiction worthy

csallen

2018-02-06
There was a strange part of the video near the end where they show the car floating through space, and suddenly a background image pops in for a second: https://imgur.com/a/ZyVqK

Any idea what that was?

EDIT: I think it's a replay of the capsule opening that initially contained the car, just spliced in at a weird part of the video.

jimnotgym

2018-02-06
That was fabulous. My son sat cheering in his space suit all the way until the live feed cut off. Can we turn a corner as a species now and look towards exploration again?

ph0rque

2018-02-06
Watching the launch with my daughter: "Daddy look! It's two daughter rockets helping the mommy rocket!"

pulkitanand

2018-02-06
They lost the center core: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-B_tWbjFIGI&t=2307

But 2/3 is impressive! Seeing the simultaneous landings had me in tears!

daniel-wer

2018-02-06
Regarding the center core, if you switch to the second stream (mission control) and go to 38:30, you can hear "We have lost the center core" - could be referring to the signal though. https://youtu.be/wbSwFU6tY1c?t=38m26s

rainbowmverse

2018-02-06
My uber is here, in the final frontier.

mempko

2018-02-06
NASA money put to good use.

thanatropism

2018-02-06
I like everything about private space exploration except this: when we sent the Voyager golden record to space, we consulted with the great minds about which were the important landmarks of our civilisation.

In this model, it's all about idiosyncrasies: the Voyager record had the Vitruvian Man, this has an astronaut on a sports car and largely-irrelevant sci-fi stories.

Of course, private space probably means the whole timeline comes faster and private associations are soon launching Dostoyevski and Pollock too. Still, this payload is culturally cringeworthy, as much as the sheer engineer accomplishment must be lauded.

gradyj

2018-02-06
Absolutely insane. I had goosebumps throughout the launch. Well done SpaceX

ninjamayo

2018-02-06
And I have to deploy a few web services tomorrow, woohoo... Elon has created a vision for generations to come, that is why today is so historic.

stanlarroque

2018-02-06
It was awesome. The synchronized landing of both boosters was emotional.

Might be a naive thought, but for a few minutes, you forget everything else. There were millions of people from every nation live-watching the broadcast and everyone was cheering and hoping for the best.

The world seemed at peace during that moment and this is what I love about space exploration and all these great human achievements.

makkesk8

2018-02-06
Man next to one of the boosters: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DVYYekSWAAEHpTa.jpg

That's nuts.

goshx

2018-02-06
This is an amazing day for all humanity.

LewYard

2018-02-06
>> [...] the rocket’s payload [...] will pass through the Van Allen belt — a zone of charged particles and extreme radiation surrounding Earth. Assuming it makes it through that radioactive beatdown [...]

What can happen ? Did a payload already exploded passing through the Van Allen belt ? Are batteries a problem ?

technics256

2018-02-06
In engineering terms, how does this compare to the most powerful rocket ever made, the Saturn V?

dmix

2018-02-06
Reposting my comment from the other thread:

Someone noticed there was a camera feed on the mission control wall that shows the Center Core's drone ship, after the smoke clears no ship can be seen: https://twitter.com/Darkphibre/status/960990105581240321

9:00 into the feed, it's likely the core either missed or failed to land properly. Although the screen is partially out of view. So this is still speculative.

woliveirajr

2018-02-06

blackrock

2018-02-06
Did they need to modify the Tesla to make it vacuum worthy?

Like, remove any fluids, remove any parts that might explode in the hot or cold of space, deflate the tires, etc.

Note: I'm more interested in a scientific answer, as opposed to casual conjectures. Preferably from an engineer knowledgeable of such things. And specifically, the materials sciences aspect of how materials will survive in a vacuum.

mspokoiny

2018-02-06
Really love SpaceX - 63 tons- this is a lot

johnvega

2018-02-06
Been watching all the previous launches. This one felt like a special moment in time.

fastbeef

2018-02-06
Wow. I can’t recall the last time I got this emotional from watching something on TV. Good thing my wife is asleep, cause I’m tear-eyed over two rockets touching down at the same time...

vvanders

2018-02-06
Starman cam is currently streaming live as it circles the earth: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aBr2kKAHN6M

iliis

2018-02-06
live view of Starman and his car: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aBr2kKAHN6M

mpweiher

2018-02-06
USA Today reports the center stage landed

"The core stage, meanwhile, burned slightly longer before separating from the upper stage, performed a flip maneuver and landed on SpaceX's Of Course I Still Love You drone ship."

Not sure it's true.

https://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/nation-now/2018/02/06/sp...

Axsuul

2018-02-06
It's impressive they got it on the first try. Their software models/simulations must have played a huge role in this, aside from other processes and engineering gotchas.

joering2

2018-02-06
Seeing two falcons landing felt to me like seeing first STS spaceship taking off all the way from Space Canaveral. Truly amazing! I cannot wait to see a version where 16 of them are landing... simultaneously! (its just a dream)

Great job Elon and team SpaceX!

matt4077

2018-02-06

clon

2018-02-06
Is there cause for concern that the payload is spinning along what looks like roughly it's normal axis. Can we assume that they equipped it with some sort of means for attitude control?

Edit: referring to the Starman live feed: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aBr2kKAHN6M

mstank

2018-02-06
Live views of the Star Man from space -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aBr2kKAHN6M

toephu2

2018-02-06
This is nothing short of amazing, but what also amazes me is the fact that 45 years ago...humans were also able to launch a payload larger than today's into orbit (Saturn V moon rocket)...that's crazy if you think about it...45 years ago?!

m3kw9

2018-02-06
What age we live in, that live video is understated

adventured

2018-02-06
Musk just posted this live feed link of Starman:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aBr2kKAHN6M

perseusprime11

2018-02-06
What does this launch mean for humans? Does this mean we can send humans to Mars on the next mission? Is there step by step plan anywhere?

runesoerensen

2018-02-06
"Update February 6th, 5:10 PM ET: This post has been updated to reflect that the center core did not land on the autonomous ship as intended."

https://www.theverge.com/2018/2/6/16971200/spacex-falcon-hea...

tambourine_man

2018-02-06
We are living in an 80's SciFi movie. This shots are amazing, I would never have believed:

https://imgur.com/a/fXdjj

muterad_murilax

2018-02-06
Is the Tesla car and it's space suit-wearing driver a reference to the intro from the 1981 film Heavy Metal?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DWMPe3wF9jQ

chkte

2018-02-06
On the one hand this is super exciting, I even cried. On the other hand, it makes me feel miserable: am I wasting my life? What have I done? Meanwhile Elon is sending reusable rockets to the space.

symlinkk

2018-02-06
Fuck Snapchat filters, fuck another JavaScript framework being released, fuck Google releasing another chat app, fuck the next iPhone having wireless charging.

This is innovation. This is the future. This, and Tesla, are the biggest technological breakthroughs since the iPhone.

dudus

2018-02-06
Can someone explain to me why are we sending a Tesla to Mars? I mean other than shits and giggles, is there any value in having it there? I assume putting stuff in the space is expensive and I wonder if that effort couldn't have gone to something more useful like a robot to look for water or whatever.

daveheq

2018-02-06
Did it successfully explode yet?

spacexyz

2018-02-06

redwood

2018-02-06
I don't get how we're seeing the views behind the car (https://cdn.teslarati.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/12/Roadste...) -- is it a green screen? special effects? something else?

runesoerensen

2018-02-06

staunch

2018-02-06
Fuck yes! Thank you everyone that worked on this and thank you Elon Musk!

AirKickBay

2018-02-06
this is amazing. mars is next

hycaria

2018-02-06
It seems I am the only one bothered by putting useless junk into the universe. I don't even know how it's possible that they were allowed to litter space just for the sake of it. Like there's not enough human garbage rotating in orbit. Couldn't they send a small probe or something more useful than a car ?

Also human space travel is just the answer to none of our current and urgent earthly problems. I don't get why people are so unreasonably hyped about it.

njarboe

2018-02-06
Love how the top comment on the successful first launch of the largest rocket since the Saturn V (with 1337 points at the moment) on a site called "Hacker News" devolves into a discussion about identity politics. Maybe we need some kind of variant on Godwin's Rule so that this doesn't happen so predictably.

runesoerensen

2018-02-06
"That core booster approached the platform as planned, but it unfortunately hit the water going 300 MPH and was lost, because some of its return engines failed to light"

https://techcrunch.com/2018/02/06/spacex-landed-two-of-its-t...

ChuckMcM

2018-02-06
Raises some interesting secondary questions; Did the starman dummy contain telemetry? At lift off? Now? If I were SpaceX this is a good way to test your spacesuit, actually in space, if you instrument the dummy its on. Pressure sensors, temperature sensors, G sensors.

Do they turn off the camera if its about to fly by something that would rather not be seen?

Flemlord

2018-02-06
Congratulations to everybody involved! One of my earliest memories is watching the Challenger launch in my school auditorium. I'm glad my daughters can have the same experience with a much more inspiring conclusion.

hnnsj

2018-02-06
This makes me excited to be human again. I need to do something more meaningful with my life.

dingo_bat

2018-02-06
It's such a shame that so many people with Elon kind of money aren't doing anything to transform us into a spacefaring species. Why doesn't apple have a mars program? What the fuck are people doing with all the money?

Awesome work by spacex. They are peerless, except if you want to count massive superpower governments as peers.

indescions_2018

2018-02-06
Congrats! To everyone at SpaceX Mission Control, NASA, and the 45th Space Wing. You are inspiring the next generation of astronauts and explorers!

At approx t-minus four minutes and counting. Elon Musk tweeted the "Holy Mouse Click" had returned "true". That moment when control is transferred to the onboard modules. And the Autonomous Flight Safety System takes control.

Its truly awesome to see that silky smooth burn. that perfect parabolic arc. And think upon the twenty-seven Merlin engines all firing in synchrony. Equipped with an intelligent decision making capability. And what the implications might be for future human spaceflight.

Here is an ancient link. But back around the mid-noughties. NASA published some details on the architecture of an AFSS:

An Autonomous Flight Safety System

https://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/200800...

Considering the Falcon Heavy includes reusable side boosters and central shaft. The complexity multiplies. As an example, take a peek at an implementation for expendable missions. that still use ground or satellite tracking and control.

Range Safety Algorithm Software Module for an Autonomous Flight Safety System

https://software.nasa.gov/software/GSC-15594-1

Darpa contributed tool for low level verification of onboard AFSS software.

SeaHorn: A fully automated analysis framework for LLVM-based languages

http://seahorn.github.io/

And of course, once your computers make it into space. They will need a place to store all the mountains of data generated ;)

SpaceBelt: space-based cloud storage network

http://spacebelt.com/

jacquesm

2018-02-06
That's going to be one very hard to overtake Tesla.

yowlingcat

2018-02-06
Like a lot of other folks on here and probably in history, as a kid, I wanted to be an astronaut when I grew up. It's hard to put into words the feelings I experienced while watching the video, and especially the landing. For all the things going on in the world (and even in my own career writing line of business software) that make me nothing but exasperated, these moments rekindle my hope and all that sense of wonderment I used to feel every moment and every day. I'm excited to see what comes next.

aresant

2018-02-06
Check 25:30 for one of the most surreal moments I've ever witnessed - they blow the top, start playing Space Man, and send the Tesla into orbit - > http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j8wxV-lUsZg&t=25m30s

rl3

2018-02-06
Official photos from today's mission:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/spacex/

abledon

2018-02-06
A Q & A is going on right now with Elon: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KORTP545vAc

ddp

2018-02-06
A wonderful inspiring art project, well done!

BurningFrog

2018-02-06
What's your opinion:

Were the two falcons landing at the same moment synchronized to look good for the cameras, or was it just how it happened because they travelled together?

runesoerensen

2018-02-06
"Third burn successful. Exceeded Mars orbit and kept going to the Asteroid Belt."

https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/961083704230674438

astronautjones

2018-02-06
"ladies and gentlemen, we are floating in space"

Animats

2018-02-06
It's so Kerbal Space Program. First Space-X built the Falcon 1, with one Merlin engine. Then the Falcon 9, with 9 Merlin engines in a circle with one in the center. Then the Falcon Heavy, with three Falcon 9 boosters side by side. Next maybe a bigger Falcon Heavy, with five Falcon 9 boosters in an X pattern.

everdev

2018-02-06
Way to make space fun again :)

Love that pic of the dummy astronaut in the Tesla looking back at Earth.

j45

2018-02-06
Starman in a convertible made me smile like a little boy. Hope it lives on as b-roll

dis-sys

2018-02-06
Leaders of the Chinese/Russian/European space programs should learn something from such launches. The message is loud and clear - your junks are no longer economically feasible for space missions.

snissn

2018-02-06
Can someone confirm if the tesla roadster is heading to Mars?

drakonka

2018-02-06
That was beautiful to watch, especially the landing of the side boosters.

zouhair

2018-02-06
Devil's advocate, here.

Am I the only one that find it quite disturbing that a private corporation taking over more public space?

In the long run this stuff will bite humanity at large in the butt.

HenryBemis

2018-02-06
You had me at "towell"!

chx

2018-02-06
In 2016, Ford spent 2.34 billion U.S. dollars on advertising in U.S. media. Total Tesla ad budget: 0. Total investment in SpaceX: 1.6 billion U.S. dollars.

sytelus

2018-02-06
Given the excitement, I have to wonder what it would have been like to watch Saturn V takeoff. It still remains the largest most powerful (and most expensive) rocket ever built. Hats off to the previous generation.

lostplesed

2018-02-06
cool

stouset

2018-02-06
I feel like I must be crazy, but did anyone else notice that the two videos from the pair of boosters seemed like they were cloned from the viewpoint of a single booster?

I don't mean they look similar. I mean they look like they came from the same video feed. When completing the touchdown, they both seem to land at the same pad -- you can see the flame of the other booster and the pad the other booster is landing at in both videos, except they aren't rotated 180 degrees from one-another because the rest of the landscape is identical. Also, watch the moment when the boosters do their initial burn to slow down from freefall. The flames in both videos look virtually identical.

Here's a few samples: https://imgur.com/a/Xpbu8

Did they acknowledge that the videos weren't actually taken from both rockets during the stream and I just missed it? Or is there some other explanation?

sir-alien

2018-02-06
“ For Sale. Tesla Roadstar, cherry red. One owner. Covered 92 million miles. Buyer to collect. ”

yujeng

2018-02-06
Wonderful feat, SpaceX! Congratulations!

But I have this one observation on watching the launch, and landing and I hope someone can explain the discrepancy to me:

How come the two boosters when they stick-landed have different colors than when they were launched - so soon? I mean, they were all real shinny white when blasting upwards from the launch pad. Are those the same ones that stick-landed to perfectly?